Amish Country Challenge: Visit Complete all three to finish the Amish Country Communities Challenge. 3 Communities for the Full Experience

Visiting Amish country once gives you a glimpse. Visiting multiple communities shows you how different each region really is.

This challenge is simple: visit three of the most well-known Amish communities in the United States and experience how each one offers something unique.

Amish Country Challenge Checklist

Complete all three to finish the Amish Country Communities Challenge.

Your Amish Country Progress

Amish Community	Visited
Lancaster County, Pennsylvania	☐
Holmes County, Ohio	☐
Shipshewana, Indiana	☐

Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Lancaster County is one of the oldest and most well-known Amish communities in the United States. For many visitors, this is their first introduction to Amish country.

The area is known for its wide farmland, roadside stands, and established markets. It’s also one of the most accessible regions, with plenty of places to stop, explore, and learn more about Amish traditions.

Why it’s worth visiting

• Strong mix of culture and visitor-friendly experiences

• Well-known markets, shops, and scenic countryside

• Easy to navigate for first-time visitors

---

Holmes County, Ohio

Holmes County is home to one of the largest Amish populations in the country. Compared to Lancaster, the experience here feels quieter and more spread out.

Rolling hills, open farmland, and fewer crowds give visitors a better sense of everyday Amish life. It’s a place where you’re more likely to feel like you’re passing through a working community rather than a tourist destination.

Why it’s worth visiting

• Less commercialized, more authentic feel

• Large Amish population

• Scenic backroads and rural landscapes

---

Planning a trip through Amish Country? You can add these stops to your personal bucket list and map out your route as you go.

Use the Way Back Tours Bucket List Builder tool to save places, organize your trip, and keep track of what you’ve completed.

Shipshewana, Indiana

Shipshewana offers a different kind of Amish country experience. While it still reflects traditional Amish life, it is especially known for its markets and local goods.

The area’s flea market and auctions attract visitors from across the region, making it one of the most active and engaging Amish destinations to explore.

Why it’s worth visiting

• Famous flea market and auctions

• Great place to find handmade goods

• Strong mix of Amish culture and visitor access

---

How to Complete the Challenge

You don’t need to visit all three locations in one trip. Many people complete this challenge over time.

As you visit each community, take note of what feels different. From the size of the area to the pace of life and the types of markets, each stop offers a slightly different experience.

Final Thoughts

Completing this challenge gives you a broader view of Amish life across different regions, not just a single snapshot.

Each stop adds a new perspective, making the experience more meaningful the more you explore.

Photo: Cab02 at the English-language Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0 Feature Photo